Pub/Sub vs. PTP: Understanding Messaging Patterns in Event-Driven Architecture

One of the core components of Event-Driven Architecture is messaging, which enables systems to communicate asynchronously and decoupled from one another. In messaging, there are two primary patterns: publish/subscribe (pub/sub) using a Topic and point-to-point (PTP) using a Queue.

Pub/Sub using a Topic

The pub/sub pattern using a Topic involves the use of a message broker, which acts as a mediator between publishers and subscribers.

Publishers send messages to a topic, and the broker distributes those messages to all subscribers that have registered interest in that topic.

This approach enables a single message to be broadcasted to multiple subscribers, which is beneficial in scenarios where there are multiple consumers for a particular message.

Publisher / Subscriber Topic

Example: ride-sharing

A ride-sharing application needs to notify its drivers of ride requests in real-time. In this scenario, the application can use pub/sub to notify all drivers who have subscribed to ride request updates.

When a ride request is made, the application sends a message to a topic, and the message broker distributes the message to all subscribed drivers. Each driver can then decide whether to accept or reject the ride request.

This approach enables real-time communication and allows the application to notify multiple drivers simultaneously, which is essential for time-sensitive applications such as ride-sharing.

Point-to-point using a Queue

On the other hand, the point-to-point pattern using a Queue involves a message broker that acts as an intermediary between message producers and consumers. The producer sends a message to a queue, and the broker holds the message until it is consumed by a single consumer.

Once the message is consumed, it is removed from the queue. This approach is useful in scenarios where only one consumer needs to process a message, and it is crucial that each message is consumed only once.

Point-to-point : Message queue

Example: Credit card transactions

A system that processes credit card transactions needs to ensure that each transaction is processed by only one consumer and that the processing of each transaction is atomic.

In this scenario, the system can use PTP to send each transaction to a queue.

Each transaction is processed by a single consumer, and once the transaction is processed, it is removed from the queue.

This approach ensures that each transaction is processed only once and that the processing of each transaction is atomic, which is critical for financial systems where data integrity is paramount.

Understanding the Difference

The primary difference between these two patterns lies in their approach to message distribution. Pub/sub distributes messages to multiple subscribers, whereas PTP delivers messages to a single consumer.

Pub/sub is suitable for scenarios where multiple consumers may be interested in a particular message, and PTP is more appropriate in scenarios where only one consumer should process a message.

Conclusion

In summary, both pub/sub using a Topic and point-to-point using a Queue are powerful messaging patterns that enable asynchronous communication and decoupling of systems.

The choice between them depends on the specific requirements of the use case, and understanding the differences between them is essential to make informed decisions when designing an event-driven system.

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *